Showdown 49ers @ Colts
- Ryan Porter

- Dec 22, 2025
- 3 min read
49ers @ Colts
Spread: 49ers −5.5 • Total: ~46.5 (moderate scoring expected)
This Week 16 primetime matchup features a 10-4 San Francisco squad looking to climb the NFC playoff ladder and a 8-6 Indianapolis club fighting to stay alive. The 49ers roll in as favorites, but the Colts are home and extra motivated — particularly with old-team narrative fuel as DeForest Buckner returns to Indianapolis.

Injury / Game Notes
49ers: WR Ricky Pearsall is OUT — removing part of the perimeter receiving mix — while DL Yetur Gross-Matos remains questionable and key players like Jordan Elliott and others are managing minor injuries.
Colts: Anthony Richardson remains OUT, so veteran Philip Rivers is starting. CB Sauce Gardner is also OUT, impacting the secondary. DE Buckner’s status is questionable but he’s activated and could play against his former team.
This shapes into a mixed offensive environment — 49ers likely control tempo through efficiency and balanced attack, while Colts may lean on chunk plays and ball control to stay competitive.
Captain / MVP Targets
(Prime pieces for massive DFS lineups — think 1.5× Captain leverage on DK / MVP on FD)
Captain Targets
Brock Purdy (QB, SF) — Efficient, low-variance floor with a good ceiling to hit passing yardage and TD totals — especially with Rivers mixing playcalls and Colts missing top corners.
Jonathan Taylor (RB, IND) — His workload and goal-line equity give huge contrarian value, particularly if Colts keep it close and near the red zone.
Christian McCaffrey (RB, SF) — Still the core of the Niners’ offense — elite receiving + rushing usage is gold for DFS. (Injury status was managed in practice; confirm gameday)
Flex / Value Plays
High-Ceiling Plays (Flex)
George Kittle (TE, SF) — TE matchups against Colts are ripe; he’s often a red-zone hedge and reception safety net.
Jauan Jennings (WR, SF) — Higher target share with Pearsall out; boom/bust is perfect for Showdown leverage.
Josh Downs (WR, IND) — If Rivers airs early, Downs could be his primary chain mover; cheap and consistent.
Value / Contrarian Plays
Michael Pittman Jr. (WR, IND) — Low floater ownership, decent target floor in intermediate routes.
Tyler Warren (WR/TE, SF) — Hidden red-zone upside and unpredictable utilization — perfect contrarian dart.
Game Script & Slate Strategy
Expected Game Flow
Moderate pace, controlled possessions: With a middling total and two veteran offenses, expect methodical drives rather than constant shootout fireworks.
Ball control through ground and short passing: Taylor and McCaffrey set tone; Rivers and Purdy mix in short to intermediate attacking routes.
Defense weaknesses: With Brewer-Gardner out and Colts secondary lighter, Niners receivers and Kittle get route room. Purdy thrives in rhythm vs. softer coverage.
Slate Construction Tips
Build around a stack: QB + RB + TE from the 49ers for consistency or pair Colts pieces if you pivot off chalk.
Leverage undervalued Colts: Cost savings with Rivers / Downs / Taylor creates diversified builds and upside in contrarian lineups.
Sample Captain Stack Ideas
Captain: Purdy — McCaffrey + Kittle (Niner offensive anchor build)
Captain: Taylor — Downs + Pittman (Colts reaction build)
Captain: McCaffrey — Jennings + Kittle (balanced SF slate leverage)
Final Thoughts
Tonight’s 49ers @ Colts MNF Showdown is a balanced DFS game with both predictable scoring avenues and leverage pathways. Lean star offensive usage first (Purdy, McCaffrey, Taylor), then sprinkle key pass-catchers who benefit from defensive absences. With controlled tempo likely, touchdowns and red-zone efficiency are the major slate swing factors — target players who can produce in both phases.
Good luck on your Showdown builds — let’s cash those lineups on MNF! 🏆



